Skip to main content

What Happens When an Item Isn’t Accepted

If an item isn't accepted, we'll tell you why and walk you through your options.

Written by Croissant Support

If an item doesn't meet our quality standards, we'll email you with options based on our team's review. All quality review decisions are final. A quick self-check before you ship helps. See What are Croissant's quality standards?.

Your options

Depending on the item, you'll see:

  • Adjusted buyback: if the item can still be resold, we may offer a lower buyback, for example to cover cleaning or a small repair before we list it. Take it, or have the item sent back to you.

  • Return: we send the item back to you, and we cover the return shipping.

  • Donate: we donate it to a local organization on your behalf.

If an item can't be resold, you'll be offered donation or return only.

Your exact options, and any details for each, appear in the app and on croissant.com when your item's review is complete.

You have 72 hours to decide

We'll send email reminders during the window. If you don't act in time, the item defaults automatically:

  • If an adjusted buyback was offered, it defaults to accepting the adjusted buyback.

  • If only donation or return is available, it defaults to being returned to you.

Once you confirm an option, or the item defaults, your choice can't be undone, so choose carefully. Keep notifications on so you don't miss the window (see Set up your notifications).

Where to find items that need action

Each item that needs your answer shows what our team noticed, along with a warehouse photo, so you can see exactly why. You can get there from a notification or from your Sales, in the app or on croissant.com.

From a notification

In the app, tap the bell icon ① at the top right of your Home tab, then open the alert that starts Answer needed on your ② to jump straight to the item and make your choice.

Two Croissant app screens: Home where step 1 is the bell icon at the top right, and the Notifications list where step 2 is an Answer needed alert for an item.

On croissant.com, choose Notifications under Home in the left menu, then click the alert that says your piece needs your answer ①.

The croissant.com Notifications page, reached from Notifications in the left menu, with step 1 marking the alert that says a BY FAR boot needs your answer.

From your Sales

In the app:

  1. Tap ⋯ at the top right of Home ① to open the Menu, then tap Sales ②.

  2. Under Needs your answer ③, above In progress and Completed, tap the item.

Three Croissant app screens: Home where step 1 is the ⋯ button at the top right, the Menu where step 2 is Sales, and the Sales screen where step 3 is Needs your answer, shown above In progress and Completed.

On croissant.com:

  1. Choose Sales under Collection in the left menu.

  2. Under Needs your answer, click the piece you want to answer for ①.

The croissant.com Sales page, reached from Sales under Collection in the left menu, with step 1 marking a piece under Needs your answer, above In progress and Completed.

On your phone's browser, croissant.com has tabs at the top instead of a left menu. Tap Collection, then Needs your answer ① (the row shows while a piece is waiting on you). Tap the piece ②, then make your choice ③. For more on getting around, see Using Croissant on Your Computer.

Three phone screens of croissant.com: the Collection tab where step 1 is the Needs your answer row, the Needs your answer page where step 2 is a BY FAR boot, and the boot's review page where step 3 is the Take the $190 buyback button.

Making your choice

Open a flagged item and you'll see everything you need to decide.

In the app

The screen names your piece and says what we can do: it has an adjusted buyback, or it's coming back to you.

  1. Under it, a note says what our team noticed and the date to answer by ①.

  2. A photo ② shows what we found.

  3. The main button ③ confirms: Take the buyback (with the amount you receive) or Return it to me.

  4. The link under it is the alternative ④: Return it to me (if a buyback was offered) or Donate it (if it's a return).

If you're not sure about what we found, tap Questions about what we found? on the same screen to reach our team.

Three Croissant app screens: the Needs your answer list with an adjusted buyback as step 1 and a return as step 2, then the adjusted buyback screen and the return screen, each with what our team noticed and the answer-by date as step 1, a photo as step 2, the main button as step 3, and the alternative, Return it to me or Donate it, as step 4.

On croissant.com

The page names your piece and says what we can do: it has an adjusted buyback, or it's coming back to you. Under the heading, a note says what our team noticed and the date to answer by.

  1. What we found shows the date your buyback or return is scheduled ①.

  2. Next to it is a photo ② of what we found.

  3. The main button confirms ③: Take the $X buyback (if a buyback was offered) or Return it to me (if it's a return).

  4. The link beside it is the alternative ④: Return it to me (if a buyback was offered) or Donate it (if it's a return).

Questions about what we found? Click Get help on the page.

A croissant.com page headed Your BY FAR Zoe Nubuck Knee-High Boot has an adjusted buyback, with step 1 marking the buyback date, step 2 the photo of what we found, step 3 the Take the $190 buyback button, and step 4 the Return it to me link.

Before your answer is sent, a pop-up asks you to confirm it, in the app and on croissant.com.

Matching sets

Each piece is reviewed on its own. If a set was bought as separate pieces and both are in your Collection, they're evaluated individually. If our team accepts one and notices something on the other, you're paid for the accepted piece and given options for the other. Once a piece is accepted, it can't be returned, so inspect each one before shipping. Sets aren't guaranteed to be accepted or paid out together.

Missing accessories

If an item arrives without one of its original accessories (a belt, strap, removable insert, and so on), our team can't accept it as sent, and you can't send the accessory separately afterward to change the result. Once an item's evaluation is complete, it can't be resubmitted. (This is different from forgetting a whole item you meant to sell. That item is marked "not received" and returned to your Collection. See Forgot to include an item in your shipment.)

Track your return

Once you choose a return, or an item defaults to one, it shows under In progress in Sales. It says Awaiting return until the carrier picks it up, then On its way back to you. Processing and USPS pickup usually take 3–5 business days.

In the app:

  1. Tap ⋯ at the top right of Home ①, then tap Sales ②.

  2. Under In progress, tap your return ③.

  3. Copy the Tracking number ①, or tap Track the parcel ② to see where it is.

Three Croissant app screens: Home where step 1 is the ⋯ button at the top right, the Menu where step 2 is Sales, and the Sales screen where step 3 is a return under In progress that says On its way back to you.

The Croissant app's return sheet, headed Your pieces are coming back, with step 1 marking the tracking number and its copy button and step 2 the Track the parcel button.

On croissant.com:

  1. Choose Sales under Collection in the left menu.

  2. Under In progress, click your return ①.

  3. Click Track with your tracking number ① to open the carrier's tracking page.

The croissant.com Sales page, reached from Sales under Collection in the left menu, with step 1 marking a return under In progress that says On its way back to you, with its tracking number.

A croissant.com pop-up headed Your pieces are coming back, listing the returned piece, with step 1 marking the Track button that shows the tracking number.

On your phone's browser, tap the Collection tab, then In progress ①. Tap your return ②, then Track ③.

Three phone screens of croissant.com: the Collection tab where step 1 is the In progress row, the In progress page where step 2 is a return that says On its way back to you, and the return pop-up where step 3 is the Track button.

The track button appears once the carrier scans the parcel. Until then, you'll see your tracking number.

Did this answer your question?